Tag Archives: exonerations

A Meaningful and Long Overdue Exchange…

I spotted him standing in line a few yards from where I sat. “Now’s your chance,” I thought to myself. Mimicking those same thoughts were ones spoken aloud by my husband, Mike. “You better go now or you’ll lose your chance to talk to him,” he urged. That was all the motivation I needed.

I stood next to him and blurted out, “Howdy!”

He turned. I smiled.

He then greeted me with similar enthusiasm and a smile that warmed my heart.

I showed him my name tag, compliments of the Great North Innocence Project (GN-IP). This evening was their annual gala which had finally brought the two of us together.

“Does this name look familiar?” I inquired. He responded with a curious “No.” It was not too surprising, given that what I was about to share with him happened ten years ago in 2015. This exchange we were now sharing was long overdue.

I explained how I had recently come across correspondence he and I had while he was still incarcerated. “I was sifting through names of all the people who’ve reached out to me over the years through my website, A Matter of Facts, and I came across your name,” I explained.

Recollection was still absent from his face.

I continued. “I nearly fell out of my chair when I saw your name, especially after hearing about you in the news following your exoneration. And then…I freaked and wondered if I had bothered to respond back to you. So…I went digging through my emails and sure enough, I found the correspondence between us. I have to be honest. Back then I received a lot of messages from people looking for help and sadly, I was overwhelmed. As much as I tried, I could not respond to everyone. Your message was so kind and respectful so it was a huge relief to know that I hadn’t ignored you.”

Marvin Haynes* stood there reconciling the details of this long lost connection. “I do remember writing to you!” Familiarity flooded his memory. “Can you send those emails to me? I’d like to see them,” he said.

“Yes, of course,” I reassured him.

“Please, I’d like you to meet some of my friends and family. They’re just over there at that nearby table.” I said. “Plus I have something I’d like to give to you.”

“Sure,” said Marvin. I introduced my husband, Mike, my sister, Clare, a friend, Mark Charron, and finally, Keith Kutska, all of whom were delighted to meet my new friend.

I then pulled my last copy of Reclaiming Lives out of the cloth bag that was hanging on the backrest of a nearby chair. Marvin glanced at it. “You wrote this? I want to write my own book, too,” he said excitedly. “Well, maybe I can help you with that, give you a few pointers,” I offered. That would be great!” Marvin’s excitement grew. I explained that my contact information was inside the book and we agreed that we’d be in touch.

I asked Marvin if he’d pose with me for a photo. He agreed and Mike took the first picture. “Oh, I should be holding your book up for the next one,” Marvin declared.

An entire month passed before I finally got around to gathering the contents of those emails onto a word document which I sent to Marvin in a private message. I reiterated who I was and included the photo Mike had taken of us (with him holding my book) at the Benefit.

To my surprise, almost immediately, Marvin tagged me in the following post on social media:

*Marvin’s story.

Donate to Marvin’s GOFUNDME Campaign

If you have thoughts/feedback about my content please feel free to share them on this site. Thank you. Take care…

Warm Breezes, Common Threads, Rippling Effects…

A beautiful summer-like evening welcomed this year’s Great North Innocence Project (GN-IP) Gala. The event themed, Ripple Effects, was held at the Nicollet Island Pavilion in Minneapolis on September 24, 2025. Joining us this year were my sister, Clare and fellow innocence advocate, Mark Charron. Also joining us for the first time was one of our six guys, Keith Kutska. Former attorneys, Steve Kaplan and John Lundquist, both of whom worked on Keith’s post-conviction appeal, were in attendance and had come over to greet us shortly after we arrived. They whisked Keith away to introduce him to other notable people throughout the evening.

We all were excited for a rare opportunity to meet the evening’s keynote speaker/exoneree, Jarett Adams.

Image courtesy of the GN-IP

Among the exonerees we met that evening for the first time was Edgar Barrientos-Quintana who was wrongfully convicted in 2009 and exonerated in 2024. I mention him in my third edition of Reclaiming Lives while citing an article written by the current Hennepin County Prosecutor, Mary Moriarty. In the article, Why I prioritized establishing a conviction integrity unit in Hennepin County, Moriarty writes, “Barrientos-Quintana’s case presents numerous issues that often show up in cases of wrongful conviction. Those include flawed eyewitness identification procedures, coercive interviews of youth witnesses, failure to disclose exculpatory evidence and failure to recognize obvious evidence of innocence once the investigation locked into a narrative of guilt.”

I shared with Edgar the mention of him in my book and gifted him a copy. I also made it a point to meet supportive family members of his who had accompanied him that evening. They all are exceptional people full of warmth.

We chatted with our friend and MN exoneree, Michael Hansen, who was dining with his wife, Shaylee, at a picnic table nearby. As I gave him a copy of my third edition I asked, “You know that there’s a picture of you in my book from when you participated in one of our car shows, right? “There is?” Mike inquired excitedly. “Yes! I also have a summary of your case and describe how we first met! Look! I said. I turned to the photo section. “Wow, that’s cool! I do remember that.” Mike recalled.

Mike Hansen speaking at a 2015 ‘Hotrod Breakout’ car show/fundraiser

As we enjoyed buffet style offerings of delectable food items at our picnic table, I kept an eye out for a specific GN-IP client who was exonerated in 2023, Marvin Haynes. Haynes had attended the 2024 Benefit for Innocence. However, that was prior to my realizing a prior connection between us. I wanted to refresh his memory of that connection and to introduce myself this time around. (This specific instance warrants a separate blog posting so, stay tuned for that.)

Joan and Marvin Haynes

Following dinner was a presentation with awards being given out and various speakers. It was then when we learned unexpectedly that two Wisconsin exonerees were in attendance. Two brothers, David and Bobby Bintz, had been represented by the GN-IP, with pro bono support from Chestnut Cambronne, and the Wisconsin Innocence Project (WIP). The brothers were exonerated in 2024 and were among the many exonerees being recognized during this event.

We made it a priority to meet the Bintz brothers, mainly because of the common thread that linked their case with the Monfils case. The same prosecutor, John Zakowski, who by the way, continues to be a Circuit Court Judge despite the growing list of overturned convictions on his record as prosecutor, is that link. We spent quite a bit of time visiting with David and Bobby, two great guys who were more than willing to pose for numerous photos.

Bobby Bintz, Clare Martinson, Joan, and David Bintz

David, Keith, Bobby  

The Bintz brothers are currently involved in a $2 million dollar lawsuit (for each) which would provide compensation for their wrongful convictions. Both entering their seventies, they have no sustaining income or other financial prospects. The standard $5,000/year with a cap of $25,000 in Wisconsin is inadequate given their situation. In fact, Jarrett Adams recently spoke directly to the Wisconsin Claims Board on their behalf about what they deserve: “…real compensation—not capped payouts and red tape.”

Clare and Bobby

Mike and David

Adams’ keynote address was inspiring, full of hopeful sentiment, and insight. His humble disposition was representative of the many exonerees I’ve met in the past. His frankness in combatting wrongful convictions and ability to now make a difference through his law firm Jarrett Adams Law sent an undeniable surge of energy throughout the entire room.

Inspiring speech given by Keynote speaker, Jarrett Adams

A philosophical analysis of wrongful convictions…

In anticipation of meeting Adams, I had prepared a gift bag which included a copy of my third edition and a copy of The Monfils Conspiracy. Following the program I approached him during a rare interval between visits with other attendees. He was so welcoming. “This is for you.” I handed the bag to him. He looked inside, excitement growing on his face. He was grateful for my gift, AND super excited to dig into both books. His assistant also examined the books with great interest.

Joan with  Jarrett Adams

“I’ll be right back. I want to put these where I won’t forget them,” Adams said as he rushed to a nearby table. He was back in a flash. We all proceeded to visit with him at length. He and Keith bonded immediately so we gave them space to converse. I spoke with Adams again later on. “How can I reach you? he had asked. “My email address is inside my book, I explained. “Great, he said. Expect to hear from me.”

Joan with Jarrett Adams and Keith 

Keith especially enjoyed connecting with Adams and many other exonerees. Having an opportunity to also meet GN-IP Executive Director, Sara Jones, GN-IP Legal Director, Jim Mayer, and so many others felt like a big deal to him. He later shared how relevant he had felt all evening and expressed the warmth that radiated from everyone he had met. “It felt like a safe place with no one judging me,” he had said afterward.

Joan, Keith, Sara Jones

Bobby,  Jim Mayer, Keith

As I continue to support and advocate for Keith and his codefendants through book events and other events similar to this, I am filled with the satisfaction of having told them repeatedly through letters while incarcerated, about the vast amount of support they have on the outside. Now…they get to experience that support in real time…

A quick note: I recently won a book award for this third edition. How fitting for a story full of champions!

My publisher embossed the decal onto the front cover image which will be present on future printed copies.

FYI: Jarrett Adams has also written a memoir called Redeeming Justice.

If you have thoughts/feedback about my content please feel free to share them on this site. Thank you. Take care…

Persistence is “Key” in a Successful Journey…

MAK banner 2024

Image courtesy of the Hennepin County Library

On July 24th I participated in a heartfelt and candid recorded conversation with Myron Metcalf; a Minnesota Star Tribune Columnist and the great, great, great grandson of Mary Ann Key. Myron is responsible for creating the Mary Ann Key Book Club.

I had introduced myself to Myron in the fall of 2024 at a book club talk at the Hennepin County Library in downtown Minneapolis. The featured speaker at that meeting was Anthony Ray Hinton, an exoneree who had written a memoir about his experience of being wrongfully convicted titled, The Sun Does Shine.

Following Hinton’s talk, I approached Myron and shared my story. I gifted him a copy of my second edition of Reclaiming Lives. My hope was that he’d read it and be so moved by it that he’d reach back out with an offer to highlight this story in some profound way.

In my futility, I often harken back to something my friend, Byron Lichstein, former Wisconsin Innocence Project (WIP) attorney had said at one of our Walks that, “Persistence and determination will be the deciding factor to move this case forward.”

Former WIP attorney Byron Lichstein at the 2011 Walk for Truth and Justice at the Brown County Courthouse in Green Bay, Wisconsin

So…after publishing the third edition* of my book, I contacted Myron again and included the link for the new edition. He responded with an offer to include my book in the library’s summer reading list. Our recent conversation in their latest Mary Ann Key Book Club Newsletter is the result. Many thanks to Myron Medcalf for this amazing opportunity!

August 4, 2025

Our 2026 season book club title and program details will be announced in February. In the meantime, the Mary Ann Key Book Club newsletter will highlight authors from the Twin Cities in conversation with Myron Medcalf about their latest books and work within the community.

Myron Medcalf and Joan Treppa discuss “Reclaiming Lives: Pursuing Justice for Six Innocent Men”

(Run time just over 15 minutes)

Joan Treppa is a social justice advocate for those who’ve been victimized by the criminal justice system. She’s best known for her unwavering advocacy on behalf of six Green Bay, Wisconsin men she believes were wrongfully convicted in 1992 for the death of coworker, Tom Monfils, a case cited as one of the most notorious injustices in Wisconsin history. With no formal legal training, Joan’s actions illustrate the power of persistence and drive to highlight the voices of those silenced. 

Her first edition of Reclaiming Lives: Pursuing Justice for Six Innocent Men, a four-and-a-half-year labor of love project, won three book awards. More importantly, it has played a significant role in the recent releases of some of the convicted men. Treppa currently resides in Minneapolis, MN with her husband, Mike.

Our journey on behalf of the six men is not yet complete. Please help out by watching the video, hitting the “like” button, and sharing it far and wide. Thank you!

*Note: If you’d like a paperback copy of this edition your best bet is to order it directly through my publisher, Kirk House Publishers. Amazon currently has it listed with an overpriced vendor. However, the pricing of the audiobook, hardcover, and e-book on Amazon are correct.